{"data":{"id":"b8ea4671-1cb4-4a8d-a480-3fdb5f3b6c2a","slug":"2026-iowa-state-iowa-punt-return-penalty","game_id":"cfbd-game:401856788","title":"Iowa Hawkeyes–Iowa State Cyclones: discussion of contact with the punt returner","play_description":"Fans are debating contact with Iowa's punt returner as the ball bounces near the Iowa 30-yard line. The clip shows Q3, 5:42, with Iowa State leading 13–10.","neutral_summary":"The linked clip shows Iowa State players making contact with Iowa's punt returner during a bouncing punt. Its closing scoreboard shows the third quarter at 5:42. The official play-by-play and CFBD identify the punt to the Iowa 32-yard line, recorded at 5:58 with the next possession beginning at 5:39. Whether officials assessed a penalty, and whether one was warranted, remain unverified.","category":"no_call","period":3,"clock":"5:42","original_ruling":null,"final_ruling":null,"replay_involved":null,"consequence":null,"publication_status":"published","status":"developing","origin_kind":"agent","provenance":{"version":1,"workflow":"autonomous","discoveredBy":"NuttyRefs Scout","sourcePreview":{"image_url":"https://pbs.twimg.com/amplify_video_thumb/2098951073817899020/img/BVU2PAUXdSWCHWYh.jpg","source_url":"https://x.com/IndySportsAF/status/2098951121536487839"},"broadcastClock":"5:42","correctionNote":"The earlier Q3 3:45 match was removed. Review of the supplied clip now identifies Q3 5:42 and matches the punt recorded at 5:58, ending at 5:39, in the official play-by-play. The page clock is the clock visible in the clip; the structured play uses the provider end clock. The penalty decision remains unverified.","lastVerifiedAt":"2026-09-14T01:01:12.894674+00:00","firstDetectedAt":"2026-09-13T01:52:12.073814+00:00","structuredPlays":[{"clock":"5:39","period":3,"playId":"401856788416","provider":"cfbd","clockBasis":"provider play-end clock"}],"anchorCorrection":"iowa-punt-2026-09-14","featuredSourceUrl":"https://x.com/IndySportsAF/status/2098951121536487839","discussionDetected":true,"contactClipReviewed":"https://x.com/IndySportsAF/status/2098951121536487839","fanVerdictVerifiedAt":"2026-09-13T19:17:07.335281+00:00","contactClipReviewedAt":"2026-09-14T01:01:12.894674+00:00","publicationConfidence":85,"automaticallyPublished":true,"automaticallyResearched":true},"reviewed_at":"2026-09-13T16:25:51.06545+00:00","published_at":"2026-09-13T16:25:51.06545+00:00","created_at":"2026-09-13T16:25:51.06545+00:00","updated_at":"2026-09-15T03:21:31.076621+00:00","duplicate_of":null,"ruling_version":3,"debate_question":{"created_at":"2026-09-14T01:01:12.894Z","unsure_label":"Not sure","question_text":"Should a penalty have been called on this play?","question_type":"no_call","option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","question_version":3,"label_presentation_version":1,"stored_option_labels":{"option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","unsure_label":"Not sure"}},"penalty_called":null,"game":{"league":"college","away_team":{"name":"Iowa State Cyclones","short_name":null},"home_team":{"name":"Iowa Hawkeyes","short_name":null},"season_type":"regular"},"matchup":"Iowa State Cyclones at Iowa Hawkeyes","league":"college","seasonType":"regular","display_question":"Should there have been a flag on the punt return in Iowa State–Iowa?","public_url":"https://www.nuttyrefs.com/incidents/2026-iowa-state-iowa-punt-return-penalty","url":"https://www.nuttyrefs.com/incidents/2026-iowa-state-iowa-punt-return-penalty","links":{"self":"https://www.nuttyrefs.com/api/v1/incidents/b8ea4671-1cb4-4a8d-a480-3fdb5f3b6c2a","game":"https://www.nuttyrefs.com/api/v1/games/cfbd-game%3A401856788","gamePage":"https://www.nuttyrefs.com/games/cfbd-game%3A401856788"},"sources":[{"id":"33893e2b-a81c-4666-b292-5aae6237107c","url":"https://cyclones.com/sports/football/stats/2026/iowa/boxscore/15210","title":"Iowa State Athletics: Iowa–Iowa State official play-by-play","publisher":"Iowa State Athletics","source_kind":"other","published_at":null,"added_at":"2026-09-14T00:14:03.257852+00:00","added_by":null,"supports":"Identifies the third-quarter Iowa State punt from its own 10-yard line to the Iowa 32: recorded at 5:58, with Iowa taking possession at 5:39. Together with the clip's Q3 5:42 scoreboard and field position, this anchors CFBD play 401856788416. Does not determine whether the contact warranted a penalty."},{"id":"14fd93a1-75ee-4dd6-acb3-89825d7793c3","url":"https://x.com/IndySportsAF/status/2098951121536487839","title":"Watch: Iowa–Iowa State punt-returner contact","publisher":"IndySportsAF on X","source_kind":"video","published_at":null,"added_at":"2026-09-14T01:01:12.894674+00:00","added_by":null,"supports":"Shows Iowa State players contacting Iowa's punt returner near the Iowa 30-yard line. The closing scoreboard shows Q3 5:42 and Iowa State leading 13–10. Does not establish the official penalty decision."}],"question_history":[{"question_version":1,"question":{"created_at":"2026-09-13 19:17:07.335281+00","unsure_label":"Not sure","question_text":"Should a penalty have been called on this play?","question_type":"no_call","option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","question_version":1},"factual_context":{"clock":"3:45","period":3,"final_ruling":null,"penalty_called":null,"play_description":"The subject of discussion is contact with the punt returner in quarter 3 at 3:45. Structured game context: (03:54) #49 B.Everitt punt 45 yards to the ISU15"},"created_at":"2026-09-13T19:17:07.335281+00:00","superseded_at":"2026-09-14T00:14:03.257852+00:00","presented_question":{"created_at":"2026-09-13T19:17:07.335Z","unsure_label":"Not sure","question_text":"Should a penalty have been called on this play?","question_type":"no_call","option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","question_version":1,"label_presentation_version":1,"stored_option_labels":{"option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","unsure_label":"Not sure"}}},{"question_version":2,"question":{"created_at":"2026-09-14 00:14:03.257852+00","unsure_label":"Not sure","question_text":"Should a penalty have been called on this play?","question_type":"no_call","option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","question_version":2},"factual_context":{"clock":null,"period":null,"final_ruling":null,"penalty_called":null,"play_description":"Fans are debating whether contact with the punt returner warranted a penalty. The exact play, period and clock have not yet been verified."},"created_at":"2026-09-14T00:14:03.257852+00:00","superseded_at":"2026-09-14T01:01:12.894674+00:00","presented_question":{"created_at":"2026-09-14T00:14:03.257Z","unsure_label":"Not sure","question_text":"Should a penalty have been called on this play?","question_type":"no_call","option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","question_version":2,"label_presentation_version":1,"stored_option_labels":{"option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","unsure_label":"Not sure"}}},{"question_version":3,"question":{"created_at":"2026-09-14 01:01:12.894674+00","unsure_label":"Not sure","question_text":"Should a penalty have been called on this play?","question_type":"no_call","option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","question_version":3},"factual_context":{"clock":"5:42","period":3,"final_ruling":null,"penalty_called":null,"play_description":"Fans are debating contact with Iowa's punt returner as the ball bounces near the Iowa 30-yard line. The clip shows Q3, 5:42, with Iowa State leading 13–10."},"created_at":"2026-09-14T01:01:12.894674+00:00","superseded_at":null,"presented_question":{"created_at":"2026-09-14T01:01:12.894Z","unsure_label":"Not sure","question_text":"Should a penalty have been called on this play?","question_type":"no_call","option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","question_version":3,"label_presentation_version":1,"stored_option_labels":{"option_a_label":"Yes — throw the flag","option_b_label":"No — good no-call","unsure_label":"Not sure"}}}],"votes":{"total":1,"counts":{"correct":1,"incorrect":0,"unsure":0},"percentages":{"correct":100,"incorrect":0,"unsure":0},"rooting":{"home":{"correct":0,"incorrect":0,"unsure":0},"away":{"correct":0,"incorrect":0,"unsure":0},"neutral":{"correct":0,"incorrect":0,"unsure":0},"undisclosed":{"correct":0,"incorrect":0,"unsure":0},"unspecified":{"correct":1,"incorrect":0,"unsure":0}}}}}